Hi! Welcome. You being here means more than you know. Knowing it resonates with you keeps me going. I'm Lavena Xu-Johnson. I write about psychology for founders. Why? Because scaling a business means knowing ourselves first.
Hey founders,
Have you noticed?
Founder-led marketing is everywhere. Anti-AI slop is everywhere.
'Humanizing' ourselves online became a thing; we are desperately looking to prove to one another that what we posted was not written by AI. (I might as well include a speling mistake just to prove my point.)
So we share our more personal opinions, lessons, and lives online.
Underneath all that is an important truth to most businesses today: being seen, as a founder, matters more than ever.
Before we share an opinion, a point of view, or a life philosophy, it belongs only to us.
The moment we post one, a private part of us becomes public, and that can be very vulnerable.
When I first started writing my thoughts in this newsletter, it felt exposing, but I can hide behind my keyboard, typing with a leg up on the desk (yes, me, now, I’m very flexible.), because all you see is my static profile pic. And the worst judgment is an unsub, which I'd rather have than a sub that never opens.
This changed entirely when I published my first video podcast interviewing founders just 3 weeks ago; it was so nerve-wracking I felt like I couldn’t breathe.
When we share ourselves in public, whether it's a talking-head video, an interview, a painting, a dance, a little poem, or an essay, what we share is a form of expression, a version of us that reaches people beyond our physical selves. We enjoy the flow of making it long before anyone thinks of it as part of a sales funnel. But when it's time to press publish, many of us hesitate, worried about how we'll look.
So I wanted to know: is that fear justified? Do others judge us, or even our vulnerable moments, as harshly as we do?
A team of psychologists in Germany ran seven studies on exactly this. Let's jump in.
This edition is kindly brought to you by Vistage
Every business hits roadblocks. The difference is how leaders navigate them. Vistage brings CEOs together to share experiences, challenge conventional thinking and uncover new paths forward. Your next breakthrough could start with the right conversation.
The beautiful mess effect
In Daring Greatly, Brené Brown wrote: "vulnerability is courage in you and inadequacy in me." Anna Bruk, a psychologist at the University of Mannheim, tested it with her colleagues Sabine Scholl and Herbert Bless. Across seven studies published in 2018, they asked around 700 participants to judge acts of vulnerability.
The first study began with a short story: You are in love with your best friend, you decide to tell them, and then you wait for their reply.
Half of the participants imagined they were the one confessing, and the other half imagined someone of the same gender, called Stephan or Stephanie, confessing.
Each participant then rated how much they agreed with eight statements about the confession, from 1 (strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree). Four of the statements were positive, such as "by showing vulnerability, I am (Stephanie is) showing courage". Four were negative, such as "…showing weakness". The researchers combined the eight answers into a single score for how positively each participant judged the confession.
Before the results, a quick poll on another situation the team tested:
A colleague admits a costly mistake to her boss that nobody would have traced back to her. What's your honest first thought?
Participants who imagined Stephan or Stephanie confessing gave it 5.19 out of 7. Participants who imagined confessing themselves gave the very same story 4.62. The story was word for word the same; only the confessor changed.

Study 1: how positively participants judged the love confession (Bruk, Scholl & Bless, 2018)
In the second study, the team tried five situations on 69 new participants. Again, half imagined themselves and half imagined someone else. They pictured showing an imperfect body at a swimming pool in front of someone they fancied, apologizing first to a partner after a big fight, asking a former boss for help, confessing a mistake at work that nobody could trace back to them (the situation in our poll), and confessing love, as before.

Study 2: light bars show participants judging themselves; dark bars show someone else (Bruk, Scholl & Bless, 2018)
In all five situations, the dark bars stand taller: participants judged someone else's vulnerability more kindly than their own.
The researchers called this the beautiful mess effect: from the outside, other people's vulnerability looks brave and even beautiful, while from the inside, our own mostly looks like a mess.
Why we see ourselves so differently
Bruk's explanation draws on construal level theory, the idea that the further away something is from us, the more abstractly we picture it. She told Psychology Today:
"We see others' experiences more abstractly, and our own more concretely. Others are 'organizing a birthday party'; we are inviting friends, cooking, and baking." "When people evaluate others' vulnerability, distance might give them a different perspective," she said. "By contrast, when it comes to our own vulnerability, the risks move closer, and we have a much better view of everything that might go wrong."
The paper goes deeper. When we picture ourselves in a vulnerable situation, our minds illustrate details: the exact words and the facial expressions of others.
When we picture someone else, we see it from further away and think about what it says about them.
Earlier research had found that this wider view makes people less wary of risk and more drawn to the upsides of a choice.
How to judge our own mess more kindly
1. Picture a founder you admire in your place
Participants were kindest when the person in the story was someone else, so we can borrow their point of view. When you’ve made a seemingly embarrassing situation to yourself, imagine a founder you admire telling you they were in the exact boat before over coffee, and ask what you would think of her.
2. Talk to yourself as you would to a friend
In a later study, the same team found that participants who were kind to themselves when things went wrong judged their own vulnerability almost as warmly as other people's.
Next time you replay a mistake, try saying to yourself what you would say to a friend who made it.
Key takeaways
We judge our own vulnerability more harshly than others judge it.
Up close, we see every risk, while from further away, people see courage.
People kinder to themselves judge their own mess almost as warmly as anyone else's.
When something feels embarrassing to us, whether it's owning a mistake, sharing a lesson from a failure or asking other founders or advisors for help, it's rarely as embarrassing as we think.
In next week's edition, I'll share evidence for something even more surprising: how exposing our mistakes and vulnerability can make us more likeable as leaders.
How's the depth of today's edition?
As always, hit reply if something in here hits home.
Until next week,
Lavena
P.S. If you want to get a founder feature about your own story, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
✨ Insane Media is more than one voice
Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the creator economy, e-commerce marketing, and Human resources.






